Caleb Flynn sat at the defense table and cried when photos showed Ashley Flynn lying still in bed after being shot. The images came from the night of Feb. 16, when he called 911 to say a burglar had broken into their Tipp City, Ohio, home and killed her. She was 37. He was 40. Their two daughters were asleep in rooms nearby.
The trial moved into its second day on Monday. A detective from the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation took the stand. He walked the court through what he saw at the scene. As the photos began to show Ashley Flynn's body, Caleb Flynn became visibly emotional and cried. He was shown weeping again after the detective testified that police determined she was shot while she was asleep.
The detective said there was no sign of a break-in. No forced entry. No struggle. No defensive wounds on her body. Two fired 9 mm cartridge casings were found on the bedroom floor. The detective told prosecutors that the amount of blood and brain matter on the bed made it hard to tell how many shots hit her at first. Later, the coroner said two bullets exited the head and caused a significant open fracture in the frontal skull.
Prosecutors told the court that Ashley Flynn was "executed." They said she was shot twice in the back of the head, lying in bed in a sleeping position. The detective said her positioning was visually consistent with someone who was asleep or lying still when she was harmed. He spent about 12 hours at the home. His conclusion was that the homicide was staged to look like a burglary.
Caleb Flynn has pleaded not guilty. He faces charges of aggravated murder, murder, felonious assault, tampering with evidence, and intimidation of a witness, attorney, or victim in a criminal case. He remains in the Miami County Jail on a $3.5 million bond. The trial is expected to last about two weeks.
On the first day, the jury heard his 911 call. In it, he told the dispatcher that somebody broke into his home and shot his wife. He pleaded with them to hurry. The jury also heard text messages that prosecutors say he sent to another woman in the months before her death. One read that he was up until 4 a.m. crying and trying to think of ways to kill her and not go to jail. Another said that if he could kill her and not go to hell, he would do it in a heartbeat. Prosecutors allege the affair was his motive.
The defense said there is no forensic evidence linking him to the murder. No gunshot residue. No weapon has been recovered. They maintain the evidence does not prove he committed the crime.
When the court saw the autopsy photos, people in the room reacted. Some suppressed sobs. Some shook their heads. The images were not shown to everyone in attendance, but the descriptions were. One photo displayed Ashley Flynn's face after death to confirm her identity. The coroner noted the open fracture from the bullets and said her left eye appeared somewhat bruised. Bone fragments were visible. Bullet wounds were visible on her arms.
Caleb Flynn once appeared on "American Idol" in 2013. He described himself as a music pastor. Ashley Flynn was a middle school volleyball coach and teacher. They had been married for almost 16 years. The couple lived in a ranch-style home in Tipp City, a suburb north of Dayton.
The detective's testimony drew the strongest reaction from the defense table. As he described the scene and the photos, Caleb Flynn fought back tears more than once. The room did not erupt. It did not need to. The weight came from the stillness of the images and the plain words used to describe them. A woman shot in bed. A husband who called it a burglary. A detective who said the scene told a different story.
What remains unknown is what the jury will decide. They have heard the 911 call. They have heard the texts. They have heard the detective say there was no evidence of an intruder. They have not yet heard from the defense's full case. They will weigh the claim of a staged scene against the lack of direct forensic links. They will weigh the grief in the courtroom against the words in the messages.
For now, the record holds a simple, hard fact. A pastor cried when the court saw photos of his wife lying still after being shot in bed. The detective said she appeared to be asleep when she was harmed. The prosecutor called it an execution. The husband says an intruder did it. The jury will decide who is telling the truth.
More on: News